Lessons Learned From Failed Feedback

Ketan Gangatirkar

VP of Engineering at Coder



I was at a presentation given by a senior executive. During the Q&A portion a question was asked of him that came across a bit entitled from the attendee. He tried to respond in a sober, dispassionate way but instead the tone of his voice and facial expression telegraphed frustration, impatience, and a little bit of disdain. Having been around this person, I knew that was not the intended effect, so I decided to give him feedback on the situation.

Actions taken

Later, I happened to be in a different meeting with this senior executive. After the conclusion of the main part of the meeting I went up to him and told him what I had observed during the earlier Q&A portion. I did it in a non-accusatory fashion but I brought it up out of nowhere. It had no relation to the meeting we were just in, making it a less than ideal setting. Plus, although I knew this person, he was not somebody that I had a high degree of intimacy and trust with.

Despite there being no clear blow back, the whole encounter felt clumsy and ineffective. Clumsy because I gave feedback in a way that relied on a nature of relationship that clearly didn’t exist. It would have been better to speak to someone on this subject whom I had a better pre-existing relationship with. Also, the conversation was too spontaneous. Finally, I didn’t set the stage properly. It was a private conversation yet it took place in a physical situation where other people were around and could listen in. Even though I didn’t consider the information super sensitive, I did not establish safety and receptivity necessary for effective feedback.

Lessons learned

  • If you don’t have that trusted relationship with somebody, consider not providing feedback. A huge part of feedback has to do with how receptive the other person is. If you are not able to establish that receptivity then the information will bounce right off.
  • Be sure that you give feedback in a private situation. Set a safe space where the other person doesn’t feel intimidated or defensive.
  • Set the stage for feedback. Make sure it’s done at an appropriate time so that the other person isn’t distracted. Find a way to break away and transition from the previous agenda into giving feedback.
  • Typically I believe that there is too little feedback given and so I am not happy with how this situation went. I don’t want to give people another reason to be hesitant about giving feedback. So I hope that my failed attempt can be useful to others. This is an example of how giving feedback didn’t go well so I encourage others to learn from my mistakes and give feedback often.

Be notified about next articles from Ketan Gangatirkar

Ketan Gangatirkar

VP of Engineering at Coder

Leadership DevelopmentCommunicationOrganizational StrategyCulture DevelopmentLeadership TrainingPerformance ReviewsFeedback TechniquesIndividual Contributor RolesLeadership RolesTeam & Project Management

Connect and Learn with the Best Eng Leaders

We will send you a weekly newsletter with new mentors, circles, peer groups, content, webinars,bounties and free events.


HomeCircles1-on-1 MentorshipBounties

© 2024 Plato. All rights reserved

LoginSign up