Back to resources

Introduction of a Matrix-Based Organizational Model in a Software House

Leadership
Engineering Processes

9 December, 2021

Jan Pieczykolan
Jan Pieczykolan

Head of IT Development at Santander Bank Polska

Jan Pieczykolan, Software Engineering Director, shares his experience changing the organizational model to matrix-based resource pool one.

Problem

Companies use multiple organizational models. One of them is a silo-based organization in which each department is a sort of a silo that manages its projects and sometimes uses some of the services offered by the company – for instance, HR, IT, etc. Usually, such a department has its P&L, and its autonomy is relatively high. As long as profits are higher than costs and margin is on the expected level, everything is fine.

The division of a company lost several contracts simultaneously; therefore, several departments grouped within this division started to lose their profitability. The situation was specific as none of the departments lost all warranties, but all were impacted. None of them could survive on its own, therefore merging was an option to recover profitability on a macro scale, on the division level.

Actions taken

We reviewed our profits and costs – to understand expected revenues and determine how much FTE we could afford.

We went through our employee list to identify those we had to keep and those we had to let go of.

We understood that we would have to prepare a flexible, matrix-based organization in the short time horizon. Our solution grouped all engineers and project managers in a single cost center while projects were grouped in programs, and programs were aggregated in separate organizational units. Those organizational units were super lean – they consisted only of a Program Director, who was responsible for a profit from a specific contract or a specific customer.

Program Directors could hire project managers and engineers only for a specific project ordered by a customer. As soon as the engagement was finished, those people were available for other initiatives. Sometimes a person could be shared by more than one project – especially in the case of small projects or maintenance contracts (maintenance contract was a project as well). We were allowing overbooking, at least to a certain level.

After some time, when Program Directors stabilized their profit centers, they started to build their own organizations as they had guaranteed income. Therefore, they were able to afford permanent hiring of employees.

Lessons learned

  • Silo organizations are often non-transparent ones.
  • Engineers can be shared by more than a project only for a limited amount of time – focus switching is usually too difficult to handle for a longer time.
  • In matrix organizations, people usually have a problem identifying who their manager is and who influences their salary and bonus.
  • Performance review in a matrix organization is complex and requires unambiguous criteria to be conducted fairly.
  • It is challenging to build innovation in matrix-based organizations.
  • It is essential to define clear responsibilities between a line manager and a project manager who engages an engineer in a project. Lack of this clear distinction will lead to conflicts and demotivation of the staff.

Discover Plato

Scale your coaching effort for your engineering and product teams
Develop yourself to become a stronger engineering / product leader


Related stories

4 E's of Leadership

21 March

A short overview of a very effective leadership assessment by Jack Welch, that is easily transferred to other industries is the 4Es of leadership – energy, energize, edge, and execution.

Leadership
Career Growth
Strategy and Vision
Ramesh Dewangan

Ramesh Dewangan

CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting

Performing Focused Work in a Distracted World

21 March

Based on an awesome book titled "Deep Work" by Cal Newport we provide provide a brief overview of the Rules for Focused Success in a Distracted World.

Leadership
Productivity
Communication and Collaboration
Ramesh Dewangan

Ramesh Dewangan

CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting

Beware the Empathy Trap

21 March

Is it possible to be too empathetic? If you overdo it, it can be an energy sucker.

Leadership
Conflict Resolution
Team Management
Managing Stress and Burnout
Melanie Zens

Melanie Zens

Delivery & Operations / Digital Transformation / Innovation at Marais Consulting Inc

Applying The Rules of IKIGAI for a more fulfilled life!

20 March

Learn about 10 rules from the wisdom of these long-living residents from Ogimi, a small village in Okinawa, Japan. You could interpret the rules as the lifestyle habits that enable the senior residents of Ogami to live long and enjoy their ikigai.

Leadership
Productivity
Career Growth
Communication and Collaboration
Hiring, Retaining, or Firing
Managing Stress and Burnout
Ramesh Dewangan

Ramesh Dewangan

CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting

Relationships, like products, need to be designed.

7 March

3 ways leaders can cultivate relationships that lead to better products.

Leadership
Building and Scaling Teams
Career Growth
Team Management
Strategy and Vision
Guy Jenkins

Guy Jenkins

SVP Global Customer Experience at Salesforce