When Words Bear More Weight
27 February, 2021
Senior Engineering Manager at GitHub
Problem
When I was an engineer on the team I was able to participate in technical conversations and share my opinion like any other engineer on the team. However, as a manager, I no longer was able to provide my technical input or opinion because people on the team would take it as a directive as opposed to another, possibly divergent, opinion.
This is not what I wanted because we have smart engineers on the team who were more familiar with the technical architecture and day-to-day problems. Moreover, the longer I stayed on as a manager, the less I was involved in the code. They were more up-to-date than I was, and I wanted to empower them to be critical and don’t take my opinion as it was. At the same time, I had extensive experience being an engineer on the team and felt that my technical input would be beneficial. But people wouldn’t argue back or push on the manager’s opinion and were taking my arguments at face value.
Actions taken
What worked -- Be the one to speak last
I decided to be the last to speak in a meeting. I would sit back, take notes, and wait until everyone had given their opinion. If some of the engineers hadn’t shared their opinion, I would prompt them to see if they have anything to add. Only after everyone had shared their thoughts would I share mine too. All the opinions would then be laid out on the table. That allowed the team to hear different thoughts instead of having only me talking.
The privilege to be the last speaker enabled me to stir up the discussion. Sometimes I would have a certain opinion on things, but after hearing some other proposals, I would be persuaded that they were better than mine. I would make sure to emphasize that and how hearing all different opinions made me revise my own.
Sitting back and keeping quiet was not easy. I would listen to people share their thoughts and, on multiple occasions, would want to interrupt them and add my two cents, but I would remind myself to keep still.
What didn’t work -- Individual encouragement in one-on-ones
I tried to bring it up in one-on-ones and explain that taking my opinion for granted was not part of the culture I wanted to build on the team. I would explain how I wanted us to build a culture where we should share opinions, and they should feel free to push back on my or leadership’s proposals. I would acknowledge their expertise and their involvement in the code and encourage them to speak up.
While I am certain that this helped a bit, it never amounted to full acceptance. They would still wait for me to share my thoughts. I also tried to speak at the meetings by abstaining from speaking from a manager’s perspective. I would say, “I have some thoughts; it’s just an opinion and certainly not any final decision.” Prefacing my statement with an explanation simply didn’t work, and they did take it at face value.
Lessons learned
- Leaders tend to take a lot of air in discussions or meetings. When they don’t listen, they unconsciously kill creativity, collaboration, and innovation, altogether. Your role as a leader is not to always come up with the best ideas but to provide more context and encourage collaboration. Because at the end of the day, the team is the one to build things, and you need to empower them to take part in those discussions. By sucking out air in the meetings, you do not allow your team to flourish, which will ultimately hurt the product.
- Be aware of how much weight your words carry. Also, be mindful of how much time you are talking and how much time you are listening to others.
Discover Plato
Scale your coaching effort for your engineering and product teams
Develop yourself to become a stronger engineering / product leader
Related stories
21 March
Based on an awesome book titled "Deep Work" by Cal Newport we provide provide a brief overview of the Rules for Focused Success in a Distracted World.

Ramesh Dewangan
CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting
20 March
Learn about 10 rules from the wisdom of these long-living residents from Ogimi, a small village in Okinawa, Japan. You could interpret the rules as the lifestyle habits that enable the senior residents of Ogami to live long and enjoy their ikigai.

Ramesh Dewangan
CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting
25 March
Oftentimes Engineers work in silos, developing products to specified requirements, while they remain disconnected from the most important of questions - "WHY are we building this?" We'll explore the consequences of this mindset, as well as how to connect your Engineers to the larger Company Vision.

Eric Adams
VP of Engineering at ExecThread
28 February
Recently I had the opportunity to remotely job shadow another Engineering Director and Mentor from Plato for a week. The article describes how the week unfolded and some of the stats and my key observations from the shadow program.

Mrunal Kapade
Director of Engineering at Inspire Energy
5 February
As an Engineering Manager, what to focus on more? People or Process or Product?

Kamal Raj Guptha R
Engineering Manager at Jeavio