Back to resources

How to Help an Underperforming Employee

Performance

22 December, 2020

Danjue Li
Danjue Li

Engineering Director at Google

Danjue Li, Senior Director of Product Software and Incubation Engineering at Equinix, tells how she dealt with an underperforming employee and how the tough conversations can help them back on the path of good performance.

Problem

For many first-time managers, one of the biggest challenges is how to deal with their underperforming employees. Lacking experience, they would struggle to identify what caused underperformance and would often take symptoms and treat them as causes. Moreover, they would have a hard time balancing their project commitments and their concerns for their reports’ growth.

Recently, I went again through the too well-known situation. An engineer who was not my direct report (but I was nevertheless responsible for them) was assigned to a high-profile project. We realized over time that they were frequently missing deadlines and not meeting the requirements. Besides, this person had difficulty being open and accepting constructive criticism from people on the team.

Actions taken

I guided my direct reporting manager throughout the process of helping their underperforming employee. I clustered my advice into four groups:

Setting up regular meetings
Though the person in question was not my direct report, I was keen to help out with my extensive experience in the matter. For starters, I suggested my reporting manager introduce weekly meetings and better understand the challenges the person was facing and use these meetings to learn what was causing underperformance and how it could be addressed.

Aligning expectations
The regular meetings’ first goal was to establish whether requirements and expectations were set clearly and whether the underperforming employee had received sufficient and adequate support to complete their tasks. We would make sure that there were transparency and mutual understanding of what success looks like.

Tracking performance
We also decided to leverage our agile processes and the two-week cadence to biweekly review the person’s sprint deliveries. We would discuss what they delivered within that sprint, dissecting problems and challenges that were particularly taxing.

Running the review process
During the review process, we would assess if the situation got improved during the reporting period. We would also do 360-degree feedback and send out surveys to people working most closely with the person. We would use that feedback as talking points during the performance discussion.

Usually, the whole process of helping an underperforming employee would last one quarter. In most cases, we would set up expectations and review results quarterly, and encourage all managers to have (bi)weekly one-on-ones with their reports. We would use sprint discussions to address ongoing challenges biweekly. If the performance wouldn’t improve a couple of springs in a row, then we could address the problem in one-on-one meetings. If there weren’t any noticeable improvement within one quarter, we would involve HR and place the person into a formal Performance Improvement Plan.

Lessons learned

  • Expectations should be set up clearly from the very beginning. Often people tend to make assumptions that are preventing them from reaching alignment and mutual understanding.
  • A manager should nurture his or her empathy. They should try to collect different information from various standpoints and synthesize them into a problem description. It is particularly helpful when, as a manager, you need to identify the root causes of underperformance and address them accordingly.
  • By their very nature, performance conversations are uncomfortable, but we should take the most constructive approach to them. Your report should clearly understand those conversations’ purpose -- they should help them get back to the expected performance and achieve their potential without hasty judgments or condemnation. You should also create a psychologically, safe environment that will allow a person to open up and acknowledge your good intentions.

Discover Plato

Scale your coaching effort for your engineering and product teams
Develop yourself to become a stronger engineering / product leader


Related stories

Managing Remotely: Balancing Team Cohesion and Focus Time

26 May

Jonathan Belcher, Engineering Manager at Curative, explains how to balance team cohesion and individual focus time, tapping into his experiences of working remotely for seven years.

Remote
Micromanagement
Meetings
Internal Communication
Productivity
Psychological Safety
Performance
Jonathan Belcher

Jonathan Belcher

Engineering Manager - Patient Experience at Curative

How to Foster and Reinforce Your Company Culture

25 April

Alex Bekker, Former VPE at Cresta and HackerOne, shines a light on how to preserve company culture throughout a growth phase and shares actionable insights on reinforcing your core values.

Mission / Vision / Charter
Company Culture
Meetings
Sharing The Vision
Performance
Alex Bekker

Alex Bekker

ex VP of Engineering at Cresta

The Necessary Structures of Time Management

14 April

Suryakant Mutnal, Engineering Manager at PayPal, discusses the importance of time management and the necessary structures in order to create internal consistency.

Goal Setting
Managing Expectations
Remote
Deadlines
Productivity
Roadmap
Prioritization
Performance
Suryakant Mutnal

Suryakant Mutnal

Engineering manager at PayPal

Three Steps to Implement a Performance Improvement Plan for an Underperforming Employee

15 March

David Hwu, Senior Engineering Manager (EM) at Tatari, describes the role of an EM to service an underperformer as well as business needs.

Alignment
Meetings
Internal Communication
Stakeholders
Toxic Employee
Performance
David Hwu

David Hwu

Senior Engineering Manager at Tatari

To Be a Strong Leader, Hire People Smarter Than You

15 March

Shawn Sullivan, Co-founder & CTO at Phase Genomics, talks about the importance of hiring and retaining people who are more intelligent or more skilled in other spheres than yourself.

Personal Growth
Hiring
Motivation
Team Processes
Performance
Shawn Sullivan

Shawn Sullivan

Cofounder & CTO at Phase Genomics

You're a great engineer.
Become a great engineering leader.

Plato (platohq.com) is the world's biggest mentorship platform for engineering managers & product managers. We've curated a community of mentors who are the tech industry's best engineering & product leaders from companies like Facebook, Lyft, Slack, Airbnb, Gusto, and more.