Effective Feedback Mechanism
5 February, 2023

Engineering Manager at Jeavio
Feedback - an ultra powerful tool but a dreaded one for many Leaders (at least for the first timers). How effectively a Leader uses this tool largely determines how effective a Leader they are.
Tools are effectively used only by skilled people. The combination of skills + tools yield great results only for those with the right mindset. Let us look at the trio of mindset, skillset & toolset to use for delivering Feedback to an individual in the team.
šš¢š§šš¬šš:
As I have mentioned in my earlier posts, Leadership is about ābuilding peopleā while building things. That should be the fundamental mindset a Leader should have.
šš¤š¢š„š„š¬šš & ššØšØš„š¬šš:
With this mindset, a Leader has to skillfully communicate 2 things while delivering feedback:
1ļøā£Ā appreciate the good work the individual did, so that they
. . . āøknow what is good work - in order to duplicate it
. . . āøfeel appreciated - hence encouraged
. . . āøhave a improved self image - to be able to accomplish more
2ļøā£ clearly communicate what needs improvement and how to improve, so that they
. . . āøclearly know the behavior/action they need to deviate from
. . . āøknow the steps to take to improve
. . . āøhave improved confidence on reaching the next level
But the divine is in the detail (yeah, positive version of 'devil is in the detail' š). And here comes the details:
⢠The way the feedback is delivered can make it a positive experience for the receiver or a bitter one.
---- I follow the 2D feedback model by Dr. Tasha Eurich, as the model focuses on future rather than the past and it focuses on the action rather than the person. This way, people are ready to receive the feedback positively and ready to act on it. Video link explaining the model in comments.
⢠What level of rapport & trust is built with the individual over several weeks to months before the feedback meeting matters a lot - a whole lot.
---- I build vulnerability based trust as explained byĀ Patrick LencioniĀ in his amazing book "The Five Dysfunctions of a Team". Video link explaining the 5 dysfunctions in comments.
⢠Knowing the career aspirations of the individual and aligning the feedback accordingly. This way the feedback becomes a great tool for the individual to stay on track to reach their own career goals.
---- And this is where regular 1-1s come into picture. The 1-1 meetings are great opportunities to build rapport, build trust and understand their career aspirations.
šš®š¦š¦šš«š²:
⤠Mindset - help the individual grow.
⤠Skillset - skillfully communicate appreciation of the good and improvement needed on what isn't.
⤠Toolset - 2D feedback model, vulnerability based trust, regular 1-1s.
Discover Plato
Scale your coaching effort for your engineering and product teams
Develop yourself to become a stronger engineering / product leader
Related stories
21 March
A short overview of a very effective leadership assessment by Jack Welch, that is easily transferred to other industries is the 4Es of leadership ā energy, energize, edge, and execution.

Ramesh Dewangan
CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting
20 March
Learn about 10 rules from the wisdom of these long-living residents from Ogimi, a small village in Okinawa, Japan. You could interpret the rules as the lifestyle habits that enable the senior residents of Ogami to live long and enjoy their ikigai.

Ramesh Dewangan
CEO at Quantum Vision Consulting
7 March
3 ways leaders can cultivate relationships that lead to better products.

Guy Jenkins
SVP Global Customer Experience at Salesforce
5 February
The Mindset, Skillset & Toolset to use while giving Feedback.

Kamal Raj Guptha R
Engineering Manager at Jeavio
31 January
Discover the daily struggles, challenges, and moments of delight encountered when delivering banking products around the world. I will share my story candidly and honestly, without filter as much as I am allowed, and offer insights into my approach while providing retrospectives of the results.

Loussaief Fayssal
Director of CX at FLF PRODUCT DESIGN